Case Studies
|
September 29, 2023

Melanie's Journey to Conquering Asthma Naturally – A Case Study Using Root Cause Medicine for Pediatric Respiratory Wellness

Medically Reviewed by
Updated On
September 17, 2024

Asthma is a common pediatric respiratory condition defined by constriction of the bronchioles, leading to subsequent wheezing and breathlessness. It can be chronic and life-altering if underlying causes are not addressed. According to the 2014 Global Asthma Report, 14% of the world's children experience asthma symptoms with genetics, allergic comorbidities, maternal health, and environment potentially contributing to its development. 

[signup]

CC: Asthma

Melanie was nine years old when she first presented with a recent diagnosis of asthma and was looking for alternative treatments to a steroid inhaler. It was June, the height of summer in Chicagoland, when Melanie was outside playing, and her mom noticed her wheezing and having difficulty catching her breath. They followed up with their primary care doctor, who did a chest x-ray, lung auscultation, and a pulmonary function test, which all proved normal. The breathing episode happened again a few days later, after which they consulted again with their primary and were given the asthma diagnosis and a prescription for a steroid and a rescue inhaler. 

Additional History:

Melanie had a healthy childhood with limited illness and antibiotic use. She lived with her family and their two pet dogs in a three-year-old house with no water damage episodes. She ate a whole-food, mostly plant-based diet with occasional chicken and fish, heavy fruit intake, and limited processed foods. She was overall a very happy and active child, enjoyed playing outdoors, was enrolled in soccer yearly since age four, and had never had breathing issues previously that she could recall.  

Overall, Melanie had regular, healthy digestion and no other concerning symptoms except her frequent throat clearing, sneezing, and itchy nose during the spring and fall seasons. She was not taking any medications and was only on a children's gummy multivitamin. 

Initial Lab Work

Melanie Case Study Initial Labs

GI Effects Stool Panel

  • Commensal balance is good with adequate levels of beneficial microflora such as akkermansia muciniphilia, lactobacillus spp., and Bifidobacterium spp. 
  • Pancreatic elastase, total protein, and fecal fats were all normal
  • Eosinophil protein X was moderately elevated at 1.8 (under 0.5 ideal)
  • Fecal secretory IgA was also moderately elevated at 1311 (under 680 ideal)
  • Negative for any potential pathogenic bacteria 

Lab Analysis 

The stool panel indicates a moderate level of inflammation, with the eosinophil protein specifically elevated, indicating inflammation and an allergic response. This, paired with Melanie’s food sensitivity panel and long history of seasonal allergies, indicates a high allergic propensity contributing to her recent asthma onset. 

Interventions

Since Melanie’s diet was already devoid of the main allergen triggers: food additives, preservatives, and artificial colors and flavors, we targeted mucus-producing foods and her now-identified food sensitivities: wheat, sugar, potatoes, tomatoes, peppers, bananas, oranges, tangerines, and grapefruit. She was told to bring in more mucus-reducing foods; dry grains like chickpeas, buckwheat, amaranth, and quinoa.

Supplemental Support

Full Breath (Organic India): an ayurvedic blend of respiratory herbs known to support bronchial health, mucus reduction, and gastric acid (low stomach acid is linked to increased food sensitivities, which further increases the likelihood of seasonal allergies and asthma). She was instructed to open 1 capsule and mix it with local, raw honey daily. 

For mast cell stabilization to reduce histamine production, as well as reduce gut lining inflammation, a powdered Vitamin C and quercetin combination product, 10 mg of zinc, and 1 gram of EPA/DHA fish oil were recommended daily. 

She enjoyed smoothies and was encouraged to brew nettle leaf tea and use it as the liquid base for those smoothies to provide additional anti-allergic support.

Lifestyle Support 

A HEPA air filter was brought into her bedroom, and they removed the area rug in her room, leaving wood floors.  

She was instructed to do a Neti pot nasal rinse with Xlear saline nasal packets added to the filtered water after coming in from playing outside. 

Follow-Up 2 Months Later

Within 2 days of beginning the protocol, Melanie noticed an improvement in her breathing, and by her second week, she was able to see a reduction in all her allergy symptoms. Her mom noted that she seemed more alert during the day and that she was sleeping deeper at night. 

Labs Repeated 5 Months Later:

Melanie Case Study Follow Up Labs

GI Effects Stool Panel

  • Eosinophil protein X: 0.2 (under 0.5 ideal)
  • Fecal secretory IgA: 522 (under 680 ideal)

At our 5-month follow-up visit, Melanie had reintroduced citrus back on a rotation basis of 1x weekly however had kept egg yolks and wheat/gluten out of her diet. She was fully resolved of all allergy symptoms after 1 month on the protocol and had not had a single episode of asthma since. 

She was instructed to continue with the fish oil and vitamin C/quercetin 3x weekly, ongoing for long-term support, but to stop the Full Breath and save it for when the spring season begins. 

[signup]

Summary

With the high co-occurrence of asthma and seasonal allergies, the reduction of symptoms on both ends helps showcase the biochemical connection driving the two processes. Targeting mast cells and reducing histamine release while also reducing gut lining inflammation with supplemental support and a complete elimination diet provided both symptom resolution as well as visible lab improvements.

Asthma is a common pediatric respiratory condition characterized by the narrowing of the bronchioles, which can lead to wheezing and breathlessness. It can be chronic and significantly impact daily life if not managed effectively. According to the 2014 Global Asthma Report, 14% of the world's children experience asthma symptoms, with factors such as genetics, allergic conditions, maternal health, and environment potentially contributing to its development. 

[signup]

CC: Asthma

Melanie was nine years old when she first experienced asthma symptoms and was exploring options in addition to a steroid inhaler. It was June, the height of summer in Chicagoland, when Melanie was outside playing, and her mom noticed her wheezing and having difficulty catching her breath. They followed up with their primary care doctor, who conducted a chest x-ray, lung auscultation, and a pulmonary function test, which all showed normal results. The breathing episode happened again a few days later, after which they consulted again with their primary care provider and received an asthma diagnosis along with a prescription for a steroid and a rescue inhaler. 

Additional History:

Melanie had a healthy childhood with limited illness and antibiotic use. She lived with her family and their two pet dogs in a three-year-old house with no water damage episodes. She ate a whole-food, mostly plant-based diet with occasional chicken and fish, a high intake of fruits, and limited processed foods. She was overall a very happy and active child, enjoyed playing outdoors, was enrolled in soccer yearly since age four, and had never had breathing issues previously that she could recall.  

Overall, Melanie had regular, healthy digestion and no other concerning symptoms except her frequent throat clearing, sneezing, and itchy nose during the spring and fall seasons. She was not taking any medications and was only on a children's gummy multivitamin. 

Initial Lab Work

Melanie Case Study Initial Labs

GI Effects Stool Panel

  • Commensal balance is good with adequate levels of beneficial microflora such as akkermansia muciniphilia, lactobacillus spp., and Bifidobacterium spp. 
  • Pancreatic elastase, total protein, and fecal fats were all normal
  • Eosinophil protein X was moderately elevated at 1.8 (under 0.5 ideal)
  • Fecal secretory IgA was also moderately elevated at 1311 (under 680 ideal)
  • Negative for any potential pathogenic bacteria 

Lab Analysis 

The stool panel indicates a moderate level of inflammation, with the eosinophil protein specifically elevated, suggesting inflammation and an allergic response. This, paired with Melanie’s food sensitivity panel and long history of seasonal allergies, suggests a high allergic propensity contributing to her recent asthma onset. 

Interventions

Since Melanie’s diet was already devoid of the main allergen triggers: food additives, preservatives, and artificial colors and flavors, we focused on reducing mucus-producing foods and her now-identified food sensitivities: wheat, sugar, potatoes, tomatoes, peppers, bananas, oranges, tangerines, and grapefruit. She was encouraged to include more foods that may help manage mucus production, such as dry grains like chickpeas, buckwheat, amaranth, and quinoa.

Supplemental Support

Full Breath (Organic India): an ayurvedic blend of herbs traditionally used to support bronchial health and manage mucus levels. She was instructed to open 1 capsule and mix it with local, raw honey daily. 

For supporting mast cell stabilization and managing histamine production, as well as supporting gut lining health, a powdered Vitamin C and quercetin combination product, 10 mg of zinc, and 1 gram of EPA/DHA fish oil were suggested daily. 

She enjoyed smoothies and was encouraged to brew nettle leaf tea and use it as the liquid base for those smoothies to provide additional support for her body's natural defenses against allergens.

Lifestyle Support 

A HEPA air filter was brought into her bedroom, and they removed the area rug in her room, leaving wood floors.  

She was instructed to do a Neti pot nasal rinse with Xlear saline nasal packets added to the filtered water after coming in from playing outside. 

Follow-Up 2 Months Later

Within 2 days of beginning the protocol, Melanie noticed an improvement in her breathing, and by her second week, she observed a reduction in all her allergy symptoms. Her mom noted that she seemed more alert during the day and that she was sleeping deeper at night. 

Labs Repeated 5 Months Later:

Melanie Case Study Follow Up Labs

GI Effects Stool Panel

  • Eosinophil protein X: 0.2 (under 0.5 ideal)
  • Fecal secretory IgA: 522 (under 680 ideal)

At our 5-month follow-up visit, Melanie had reintroduced citrus back on a rotation basis of 1x weekly but had kept egg yolks and wheat/gluten out of her diet. She experienced a significant reduction in allergy symptoms after 1 month on the protocol and had not had a single episode of asthma since. 

She was advised to continue with the fish oil and vitamin C/quercetin 3x weekly, ongoing for long-term support, but to reserve the Full Breath for when the spring season begins. 

[signup]

Summary

With the high co-occurrence of asthma and seasonal allergies, the reduction of symptoms on both ends helps illustrate the potential connection between these processes. Supporting mast cells and managing histamine release while also supporting gut lining health with supplemental support and dietary adjustments provided both symptom management as well as visible lab improvements.

The information in this article is designed for educational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for informed medical advice or care. This information should not be used to diagnose or treat any health problems or illnesses without consulting a doctor. Consult with a health care practitioner before relying on any information in this article or on this website.

Learn more

No items found.

Lab Tests in This Article

  1. Bhusal, K. K., Magar, S. K., Thapa, R., Lamsal, A., Bhandari, S., Maharjan, R., Shrestha, S., & Shrestha, J. (2022). Nutritional and pharmacological importance of stinging nettle (Urtica dioica L.): A review. Heliyon, 8(6), e09717. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e09717
  2. Global asthma network the global asthma report. (2014). http://globalasthmareport.org/2014/Global_Asthma_Report_2014.pdf
Order from 30+ labs in 20 seconds (DUTCH, Mosaic, Genova & More!)
We make ordering quick and painless — and best of all, it's free for practitioners.

Latest Articles

View more on Case Studies
Subscribe to the magazine for expert-written articles straight to your inbox
Join the thousands of savvy readers who get root cause medicine articles written by doctors in their inbox every week!
Thanks for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Are you a healthcare practitioner?
Thanks for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Subscribe to the Magazine for free to keep reading!
Subscribe for free to keep reading, If you are already subscribed, enter your email address to log back in.
Thanks for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Are you a healthcare practitioner?
Thanks for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Trusted Source
Rupa Health
Medical Education Platform
Visit Source
Visit Source
American Cancer Society
Foundation for Cancer Research
Visit Source
Visit Source
National Library of Medicine
Government Authority
Visit Source
Visit Source
Journal of The American College of Radiology
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
National Cancer Institute
Government Authority
Visit Source
Visit Source
World Health Organization (WHO)
Government Authority
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Journal of Pediatrics
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
CDC
Government Authority
Visit Source
Visit Source
Office of Dietary Supplements
Government Authority
Visit Source
Visit Source
National Heart Lung and Blood Institute
Government Authority
Visit Source
Visit Source
National Institutes of Health
Government Authority
Visit Source
Visit Source
Clinical Infectious Diseases
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Brain
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Journal of Rheumatology
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Journal of the National Cancer Institute (JNCI)
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Journal of Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Hepatology
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Kidney International
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Annals of Surgery
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Chest
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Blood
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Gastroenterology
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The American Journal of Psychiatry
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Diabetes Care
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Journal of the American College of Cardiology (JACC)
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Journal of Clinical Oncology (JCO)
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Journal of Clinical Investigation (JCI)
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Circulation
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
JAMA Internal Medicine
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
PLOS Medicine
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Annals of Internal Medicine
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Nature Medicine
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The BMJ (British Medical Journal)
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
The Lancet
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA)
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Pubmed
Comprehensive biomedical database
Visit Source
Visit Source
Harvard
Educational/Medical Institution
Visit Source
Visit Source
Cleveland Clinic
Educational/Medical Institution
Visit Source
Visit Source
Mayo Clinic
Educational/Medical Institution
Visit Source
Visit Source
The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM)
Peer Reviewed Journal
Visit Source
Visit Source
Johns Hopkins
Educational/Medical Institution
Visit Source
Visit Source

Hey practitioners! 👋 Join Dr. Chris Magryta and Dr. Erik Lundquist for a comprehensive 6-week course on evaluating functional medicine labs from two perspectives: adult and pediatric. In this course, you’ll explore the convergence of lab results across different diseases and age groups, understanding how human lab values vary on a continuum influenced by age, genetics, and time. Register Here! Register Here.

Hey practitioners! 👋 Join Dr. Terry Wahls for a 3-week bootcamp on integrating functional medicine into conventional practice, focusing on complex cases like Multiple Sclerosis. Learn to analyze labs through a functional lens, perform nutrition-focused physical exams, and develop personalized care strategies. Register Here.