Alcohol Use and Health Outcomes: A Prospective Study on Mortality, Heart, and Kidney Disease

Many of us enjoy a glass of wine with dinner or a beer after work, but it is crucial to understand the impact of alcohol on our health. Whether you prefer red wine, beer, or spirits, the type and amount you consume can significantly affect your heart, kidneys, and overall well-being.

In 2024, a prospective cohort study published in Medicine examined how different types of alcohol influence our health. With over 500,000 participants, the study's findings offer surprising insights that might change how you view your drinking habits.

[signup]

The Study At A Glance

Researchers set out to determine how consuming various types of alcohol impacts heart disease, kidney disease, and all-cause mortality. They aimed to understand whether certain types of alcohol might offer protective benefits or pose health risks.

The study followed over 500,000 participants, aged 40 to 69, who were recruited between 2006 and 2010 and tracked for about 12 years. Participants reported their alcohol consumption, including the types and amounts of alcohol they drank, such as red wine, champagne plus white wine, beer, fortified wine, and spirits. 

Researchers also collected demographic information and lifestyle factors, including age, sex, ethnicity, education level, smoking status, diet, and physical activity levels, with a balanced representation of both men and women.

Using national health records, researchers documented incidences of heart disease, kidney disease, and deaths over the follow-up period. This comprehensive data allowed for a detailed comparison of the health effects of different types and amounts of alcohol. 

By adjusting for variables such as age, sex, education level, smoking status, diet score, and exercise score, the study aimed to provide a clear and reliable analysis of alcohol's impact on health.

Key Findings

The study suggested the following:

Heart Disease and All-Cause Mortality

The study revealed a U-shaped relationship between alcohol consumption and both heart disease and all-cause mortality rates. Moderate drinkers exhibited lower risks of heart disease and death compared to both heavy drinkers and non-drinkers. 

Heavy drinkers and abstainers had similarly higher risks, indicating that both excessive and no alcohol intake were detrimental.

Kidney Disease

The study found that moderate alcohol consumption is linked to a reduced risk of chronic kidney disease (CKD), with protective effects seen in beverages like red wine, white wine, beer, and fortified wine. 

This benefit was not observed in heavy drinkers or non-drinkers, highlighting the unique advantage of moderate drinking for kidney health. The protective effect is attributed to the beneficial non-alcoholic components present in these beverages.

Impact of Different Types of Alcohol

Moderate consumption of red wine, champagne, white wine, and beer was linked to lower risks of cardiovascular disease (CVD), all-cause mortality, and chronic kidney disease (CKD). Red wine showed the most significant protective effects. Fortified wine provided some protective effects, though less pronounced.

In contrast, spirits were associated with an increased risk of CVD and did not offer the protective benefits seen with other alcoholic beverages.

Thresholds for Safe Consumption

The study identified safe alcohol consumption thresholds as less than 11 grams per day for males and less than 10 grams per day for females. Specific limits for different types of alcohol were also determined: 

• Red wine, less than 7 glasses per week for males and 6 for females
• Champagne and white wine, less than 5 glasses per week
• Fortified wine, less than 4 glasses per week
• Beer, less than 2 pints per week for females

These findings aim to balance the health benefits and risks associated with alcohol consumption.

Protective Effects Under Safe Doses

Alcoholic beverages consumed within safe doses exhibited protective effects against several conditions. Moderate consumption of red wine, champagne plus white wine, beer, and fortified wine was linked to lower risks of diabetes, depression, dementia, epilepsy, liver cirrhosis, and other digestive diseases. 

Consumption within these safe thresholds did not increase cancer risk, making moderate amounts potentially beneficial for overall health.

Significance of the Findings

These findings challenge the notion that all alcohol consumption is harmful, showing that moderate drinking, particularly of certain types of alcohol, can offer protective health benefits. 

The study provides insights into how different alcoholic beverages affect health, indicating that red wine, white wine, and beer, when consumed within safe limits, may reduce the risks of cardiovascular disease, all-cause mortality, and chronic kidney disease. 

These results refine previous research by specifying safe consumption thresholds and comparing the effects of various types of alcohol on different health outcomes, supporting a more informed approach to moderate drinking as part of a healthy lifestyle.

Clinical Application

These findings guide healthcare practitioners in advising clients on safe alcohol consumption. They recommend up to 11 grams daily for men and 10 grams for women, preferring red wine, white wine, and beer over spirits and spreading intake throughout the week. 

This approach aims to lower the risks of cardiovascular disease, all-cause mortality, and chronic kidney disease.

Limitations of the Study

The study relied on self-reported data, which can be inaccurate. Its observational nature identifies associations but cannot establish cause-and-effect relationships. It did not account for all potential confounding variables, such as genetic predispositions and environmental factors.

The findings may not be generalizable to other ethnic groups or populations with different lifestyles, as they predominantly involved white participants from the UK Biobank. The follow-up period, although extensive, may still be insufficient to capture the long-term health effects of alcohol consumption.

Functional Medicine Labs for Evaluating Alcohol Consumption

Functional medicine labs offer specialized tests to assess alcohol consumption, such as the Carbohydrate-Deficient Transferrin (CDT) test by Access Labcorp Draw and the CDT panel by Access Med Labs. These tests, available through Rupa Health, help identify alcohol-related health issues and support more effective management strategies.

[signup]

Key Takeaways

• Moderate drinking, up to 11 grams of alcohol per day for men and 10 grams per day for women, can be incorporated into a healthy lifestyle. It's crucial to adhere to these limits to avoid health risks.
• The type of alcohol consumed matters. Red wine, white wine, and beer have been shown to offer more protective effects against cardiovascular disease and chronic kidney disease compared to spirits, which are linked to higher health risks.
• Regular health monitoring, including lab tests, is essential to track how alcohol consumption impacts your body, ensuring you stay within safe consumption limits and maintain overall health.